Relationships | 09/10/2009 12:30 am
9 Signs Your Friend Is Toxic
Susan Shapiro Barash, author of Toxic Friends: The Antidote for Women Stuck in Complicated Friendships, on how to tell when your friendship is unhealthy … and how to disengage.

The colloquial term "frenemy" was coined to describe a complicated relationship wherein a person causes a friend such pain and anguish that there is a blur between this person being your "friend" or "enemy." Why is it so hard to tell the difference between the two opposite words that society had to create a fuzzy word to describe a shade of gray? For one, our parents didn’t raise us with built-in "bad friend sensors" because our girlfriends are different to us than they were to our mothers or grandmothers, explains Susan Shapiro Barash, a nationally regarded gender expert and author of Toxic Friends: The Antidote for Women Stuck in Complicated Friendships, an upcoming tome on dealing with female relationships.
With advances in communication technologies, such as Skype and Facebook, women have been able to move farther away from their mothers and siblings in pursuit of their careers and families. And during the process, women sought the comfort of nearby friends on whom to depend, as though they shared the same DNA.
"My grandmother didn’t need a book like this,” Shapiro tells us. "Her family didn’t live three thousand miles away. Today, what women look for in female friendships is what they would look for in a relationship with their mother or sister."
Additionally, our grandmothers weren’t going to restaurants to meet with girlfriends to talk about their sex lives, careers and health. According to Barash, it appears that these types of gatherings grew from women who sought the deep connections seen on popular television series, such as "Sex & The City" and "Friends." Shows that highlighted female kinships that are just as strong — if not tighter — than family ties have become a model for real-life social circles and in turn women have grown to trust friends with very private matters. It’s also natural for women to turn to the comfort of friends when they grow older and lose their mothers, sisters and significant others.
Hence, friends have become a fabric of our lives — which also explains why it hurts us so when a friendship is fraught with confusion, heartache and tears. Let’s face it: A bitchy friend is just as scarring as a bad mother or husband. This is similar to the conclusion made by Barash, which compelled her to explore the key components of damaging relationships and also provide women advice on how to detect such harmful friendships. Here we asked Barash to share with wowOwow the signs of a toxic friendship — and how to disengage.
The 9 Signs You’re in a Toxic Friendship
1) Your friend is jealous of you. Jealousy is different than envy and the first can be very toxic for the relationship. Jealousy is: "I want what you have and I want you dead or disappeared." Envy is just: "I want what you have." A jealous friend will want to cut you out of her life because she really wants what you have and can’t stand to be around you anymore. An envious friend will want what you have, but will look to you as her inspiration or role model, and compete with you to get in the lead.
2) Your friend is a "doormat": It’s tiring to always be with someone who is so malleable.
3) Your friend wasn’t there for you. It’s sometimes hard to see if a friend is really a true pal until there is a life-changing moment in your life that requires the person’s support. This eye-opening event is called The Inciting Incident, which is when everything is going along fine, until wham! someone gets sick, or loses their job, or gets married or loses a loved one, and you find that the friend you thought would be by your side isn’t there for you at all. She doesn’t celebrate your good news nor does she help you in times of need. For some women it takes an "inciting incident" to finally notice that a friend is toxic.























85 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
I never really though about how much jealousy plays apart in my friendships….I could never really understand why I don’t seem to have close friends around when I need them. But with age I realized that many of my friends were jealous of things I had and they did not. It really hurts now to have grown up with people my whole life and to find out now they dont really care about me at all.
I like this article and look forward to reading more in the book.
hmmmnnnn. interesting to contemplate what my world would look like if i had the NERVE to jettison those with toxic tendencies. Perhaps Ms. Barash’s insights will give me the nerve to examine these relationships more closely. Then again, if too closely—I could be friendless. Thank goodness for my real sisters (sisters take note.) Looking forward to reading more.
Susie
I dont know what I would do with out my girlfriends! They have helped me thru everything in life…I have had the jealous friend…I have been the dormat…I think I have gone thru it all.
Now what I look for the most in a friendship is trust and someone that is really there for me…Women have the tendency to be at odds with one another. Espeically as you get old, it is hard to make new friends. Every woman has different types of friends…its good to have a forum to talk about these different kind of friends and the impact they can have on your life.
Rose,
I understand what you wrote because it is familiar to me, and I am no femme fatale, dangerous to all, never was. When my husband & I split I told friends it was not a civl war and they didn’t have to choose sides. I anticipated that some couples would find it awkward at times, but I never anticipated this rigid protocol which prevails everywhere including places where there are retirees; women lunch together, and couples have dinner together, and never the twain shall meet. I live in Manhattan, and old friends, the twosies, come for dinner and theater, but never have any of them invited me to join them, though they know that I always pay for myself, and don’t depend on transportation. I’ve known some since high school, some are former colleagues, and some are former neighbors. Sadly, I’ve finally accepted this awful exclusion, but I still wonder why such rigid practices. After all, when married these folks had dinner at our place, and I never had an even number of guests.
This summer I took 2 suburban trains to attend an 80th birthday party and wedding anniversary of friends my husband and I knew for 50 years. Guess where I sat! Though there were former colleagues and friends, all couples sitting at the same tables, I was seated at a table near the awful band, and I knew no one there. I introduced myself, but no one responded. Eventually, I was introduced to a man, recently widowed, a former acquaintance who used to visit us, together with his wife and children, a long time ago, and the conversation was limited because he was still adapting to being single. When I returned home, I was devastated. My married friends never even thought of coming over to chat, and yet, if I now invite them to my place they would come running because they enjoy my cooking and conversation.
Two weeks ago, my children held birthday party for me, and told me to make up the guest list. For the first time, I decided not to invite several couples, some of whom had attended the earlier party, because their manners are crude. However, my birthday celebration was filled with laughter and joy, and my younger friends, family, former students, and their families and I enjoyed the evening without Mr. & Mrs.
What is so strange about this hurtful practice is that inevitably every couple will face the same loss, whether by death or divorce. But now, they can’t empathize or recognize my worth—-or could it be that they are envious of my independence and spirit; more than 20 years ago when I announced our imminent divorce, several long married women told me,"I’ve thought of it, but don’t want to be alone." So, I suspect they anticipated I’d fall apart, but I haven’t. Instead, I have a good life, travel alone whenever I wish, try to find new, more compatible friends, and know that these smug former companions are now toxic. So be it. We older singles fend for ourselves, and know better.