Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Relationships | 09/10/2009 12:30 am

9 Signs Your Friend Is Toxic

Susan Shapiro Barash, author of Toxic Friends: The Antidote for Women Stuck in Complicated Friendshipson how to tell when your friendship is unhealthy … and how to disengage.

By Randi Bernfeld
© Shutterstock

The colloquial term "frenemy" was coined to describe a complicated relationship wherein a person causes a friend such pain and anguish that there is a blur between this person being your "friend" or "enemy." Why is it so hard to tell the difference between the two opposite words that society had to create a fuzzy word to describe a shade of gray? For one, our parents didn’t raise us with built-in "bad friend sensors" because our girlfriends are different to us than they were to our mothers or grandmothers, explains Susan Shapiro Barash, a nationally regarded gender expert and author of Toxic Friends: The Antidote for Women Stuck in Complicated Friendships, an upcoming tome on dealing with female relationships.

With advances in communication technologies, such as Skype and Facebook, women have been able to move farther away from their mothers and siblings in pursuit of their careers and families. And during the process, women sought the comfort of nearby friends on whom to depend, as though they shared the same DNA.

"My grandmother didn’t need a book like this,” Shapiro tells us. "Her family didn’t live three thousand miles away. Today, what women look for in female friendships is what they would look for in a relationship with their mother or sister."

Additionally, our grandmothers weren’t going to restaurants to meet with girlfriends to talk about their sex lives, careers and health. According to Barash, it appears that these types of gatherings grew from women who sought the deep connections seen on popular television series, such as "Sex & The City" and "Friends." Shows that highlighted female kinships that are just as strong — if not tighter — than family ties have become a model for real-life social circles and in turn women have grown to trust friends with very private matters. It’s also natural for women to turn to the comfort of friends when they grow older and lose their mothers, sisters and significant others.

Hence, friends have become a fabric of our lives — which also explains why it hurts us so when a friendship is fraught with confusion, heartache and tears. Let’s face it: A bitchy friend is just as scarring as a bad mother or husband. This is similar to the conclusion made by Barash, which compelled her to explore the key components of damaging relationships and also provide women advice on how to detect such harmful friendships. Here we asked Barash to share with wowOwow the signs of a toxic friendship — and how to disengage.

The 9 Signs You’re in a Toxic Friendship

1) Your friend is jealous of you. Jealousy is different than envy and the first can be very toxic for the relationship. Jealousy is: "I want what you have and I want you dead or disappeared." Envy is just: "I want what you have." A jealous friend will want to cut you out of her life because she really wants what you have and can’t stand to be around you anymore. An envious friend will want what you have, but will look to you as her inspiration or role model, and compete with you to get in the lead.

2) Your friend is a "doormat": It’s tiring to always be with someone who is so malleable.

3) Your friend wasn’t there for you. It’s sometimes hard to see if a friend is really a true pal until there is a life-changing moment in your life that requires the person’s support. This eye-opening event is called The Inciting Incident, which is when everything is going along fine, until wham! someone gets sick, or loses their job, or gets married or loses a loved one, and you find that the friend you thought would be by your side isn’t there for you at all. She doesn’t celebrate your good news nor does she help you in times of need. For some women it takes an "inciting incident" to finally notice that a friend is toxic.

85 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Gail Clott

TOXIC FRIENDS - Susan has again titled a book that grabs your attention. Wkhat makes a "great friend" is one who doesn’t have more than a touch of the 9 components described by Susan.  But, the worst for me is the friend who is draining you - when it’s all about them.  There’s no way to openly discuss the problem with that friend, she’ll just turn the conversation to herself.  Better to let that "friend" slip away.  By Emma  

 

By Gail Clott on 09/11/2009 12:43 pm
Helene Barash

I agree with premise of the author.Never written better.Easy to read. Incitful and very helpful.kudos to Susan for expressing it as it is.And how to deal with problem friends. This is a winner and not to be missed

by helene moses on o9/11/2009

By Helene Barash on 09/11/2009 12:58 pm
selma meyerson
Shapiro Barash hits the 9 points right on the head. Can’t wait for Toxic Friends to hit the book store so I preordered copies from Amazon to give to my 5 grandchildren to better alert them in selecting friends during life. Selma Meyerson
By selma meyerson on 09/11/2009 1:05 pm
christine florio

Finding a loyal and honest friend is extremely hard to find, but trying to get rid of a "toxic" one is even harder. I am looking forward to reading Susan’s book and can’t wait to see the advice she gives on this topic.

By christine florio on 09/11/2009 7:47 pm
Rain in Minneapolis
I noticed that when I start a new job or join a new group, etc. the first person to run up to you and "befriend" you is always the one who later turns out to be your biggest problem.  They really only are interested in knowing personal information about you so they can gossip about you or compare you with themselves to see how they measure up (jealous).  The people that graciously take their time to get to know you usually turn out to be solid, decent friends without ulterior motives.
By Rain in Minneapolis on 09/12/2009 9:52 am
Karen R
That’s not my friend, that’s my mother.
By Karen R on 09/12/2009 10:23 am
L. C.

Once I discover who you are, you’re gone if you’re toxic. If I can’t trust you then there’s no hope for a relationship period! If you’re family I love you from a distance.

I give you 100% going into a relationship and leave it up to you to show who you are. If you screw things up, that’s on you. I don’t waste time on toxic persons. Life is too short!

By L. C. on 09/12/2009 10:26 am
A Marius
I enjoy reading all of Susan’s books, I can certainly relate to this one, since most of my friends have proven to be toxic. I can’t wait to get hold of this new one Toxic Friends, ha, ha. I am sure it is a must read!
By A Marius on 09/13/2009 10:34 am
Thelma Leopold

I have had toxic friends or maybe I have been a toxic friend and did not know it. I don’t like friends to ask me not to tell a secret, I am the type who does not have to know everything. I have asked people not to tell me, if it’s a secret.

Another type of friend who I think is toxic, the one who always has bad news. My test is when there is a problem, most of the times, my friends are not there, except the one who is telling you who should be your friends.

By Thelma Leopold on 09/13/2009 6:35 pm
Janet Smith
OMG-my "best friend" whom I went to high school with and roomed with in college-going on 37 years now, was a toxic friend all these years and this article just made me realize it.  She has had many, many secrets that I had to keep.  I realize now how much it took a toll on me all these years…………her numerous abortions in high school and college and smoking cigarettes that she didn’t want her family to know.  Then on to her numerous affairs from the first year she was married.  And then there was the jealousy she had for me that I knew deep down in side, but just realized now too. She dumped me as a friend a month ago when all this finally came to a head when I told her I wasn’t keeping secrets anymore.  Now I know it was her jealousy and my burden.  It’s really a relief now that I am separated from her and all the secrets. We just didn’t share the same values, she was somebody different to me than to the rest of the world. I was the one who knew all the secrets, and she was "Miss Goody Two Shoes" to her family, husband and friends.  Sometimes a long time friendship like that just blinds you to their real motivations. 
By Janet Smith on 09/13/2009 9:09 pm
kermie b
Oh please.  If a friend is toxic, you know it.  It doesn’t take a brain trust or the next hot book to see that.  I have a handful of friends who are there for me in good times and bad.  As you get older the number gets smaller and more precious—because it is real.
By kermie b on 09/14/2009 12:50 am
Ro H
Oh please.  If a friend is toxic, you know it.  It doesn’t take a brain trust or the next hot book to see that.  I have a handful of friends who are there for me in good times and bad.  As you get older the number gets smaller and more precious—because it is real. By kermie b on 09/14/2009 12:50 am kermie b - I reacted kind of the same way as you…  It doesn’t take a genius to recognize toxic friends, but… it does take intelligence to realize we don’t have to keep them in our lives. I pretty much leave it up to my "gut" if I get a tightness in my stomache, when they are around, it usually means I am feeling tense around them.  Or, they just outright make me feel crazy when they come around - which means they are getting on my last nerve!  I rely on my instincts - they almost never fail.
By Ro H on 09/16/2009 1:56 am
kermie b
Ro H—I agree.  And those same instincts tell you when you have a keeper, right?  I have core friends I have known since grade school, high school, college—all who have my back when times get tough, I don’t even have to ask them, they are just there.  I am there for them, also, but I have always wondered how I lucked out.  I have had a few toxic friendships in the past, the kind where you say goodbye to the person and they don’t want to let go—I listen to them, try to see it from their side, before I say "this is not ever going to work out".  You are right, it is a gut reaction.  Oh, the stories. 
By kermie b on 09/16/2009 7:21 am
Ro H

Ro H—I agree.  And those same instincts tell you when you have a keeper, right?  I have core friends I have known since grade school, high school, college—all who have my back when times get tough, I don’t even have to ask them, they are just there.  I am there for them, also, but I have always wondered how I lucked out.

kermie b

I submit to you - one who has friends such as you, is all a good friend to have…

You seem to have a good sensibility, and that certainly does help when it comes to friendships.  Blessings!

Ro H

By Ro H on 09/19/2009 8:43 pm
Ro H
is all a good friend to have… correction - is also a good friend to have.
By Ro H on 09/19/2009 8:46 pm