Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

A Friend Stopped By | 10/20/2009 3:00 am

The Truth About Marriage, by Carin Rubenstein

The author of a controversial new book explains why egalitarian partnerships are the exception, not the rule
By Carin Rubenstein
Carin Rubenstein

Editor’s Note: Carin Rubenstein is the author of The Superior Wife Syndrome, just published by Touchstone. She holds a PhD in social psychology from New York University.

A few years ago, I received a metaphorical wake-up call from Marriage Problem Central, informing me that my state of matrimony was out of
whack.

That pivotal midlife moment came when my husband and I were visiting our extended family in Washington, D.C., to celebrate our daughter’s college graduation. We don’t live nearby, so I’d ordered a cake ahead of time, from a bakery located a mile or so from our hotel. The day of the celebration, I asked my husband of several decades if he’d mind getting in the car to pick up the cake, which I’d paid for in advance.

Doing less is the male default position, while the female default setting is to do more and more until we do nearly everything.

He was adamant in his sincere — and definitive — refusal. "I don’t want to have to think," is what he said, as if that were not part of our connubial arrangement. And it’s not, actually.

See, thinking is what I do; that’s my job in our marriage. Going along to get along is what he does. I’m in the driver’s seat, he’s along for the ride, sitting shotgun while he stares out the window or fiddles with the radio.

Works for him.

The question is: What’s it doing for me? Answer: Not one damn thing.

In the years since that weekend, I’ve discovered that there are millions of wives who share my fate. After studying the matter — I’m a social psychologist and survey researcher — I have come to realize that my situation was predicated on being a superior wife: I’m the one in the marriage whose job it is to do all of the heavy thinking.

Let’s backtrack for a moment. As newlyweds, many of us expect to enter a true partnership when we marry, just as I did. But over time, and especially after having children, these egalitarian arrangements are often transformed into an unrecognizably lopsided state of affairs. Wives end up doing almost everything, including bringing home the bacon; husbands wait for it to fry up in the pan.

It took me much too long to realize that this is what had happened in my own marriage, mostly because it happened so slowly and so naturally, as if it were inevitable. But soon after that weekend in Washington, I realized that I was wedded to a hair-losing, chore- and responsibility-evading extra child.

I had become my husband’s keeper.

This is, as it turns out, the marital dilemma of the moment. My conjugal imbalance is part of a much larger, more widespread problem. Like me, many wives have become the superior members of their union, because they have no choice in the matter. Men do less because they can, because their wives let them slide. Doing less is the male default position, while the female default setting is to do more and more until we do nearly everything.

57 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

joan larsen

When you marry young, have your children one after another like stepping stones, no one tells you about division of duties.  In looking back, we both pitched in when it got "too much".  And as I remember, it got to be too much often.  . as caring for children often is.  We did the best job we could to set the kids off in the right direction - and I still believe it was the example we set, the love we gave, that made the difference.  We have fewer worries about them as adults … and wonder of wonders, they seem to have followed in our footsteps - something that doesn’t always happen we have found.

But it was time for us now — and we each had our own high goals in life, quite separate from the other.  Now was OUR hour to begin to shine.  We exalted - as I look back - hugging each other as each moved up the ladders we had chosen - and the pride equated somehow to make the love we felt even stronger.  Each was the other’s strongest advocate; each was the other’s strongest rooting section.  It was like a two trees growing up and joining forces, having strong roots and branches that reached for the light, for the sky.  We were independent in the paths we took after the children had started on their own roads, with goals that took flavors of their own. 

Looking back, I think each of us squeezed in all our separate dreams and ambitions, but drew even closer in congratulation of each other.  In other words, love flourished and still does.  There is joy in our married life … we are not joined at the hip.  We are separate individuals with high, apple pie in the sky hopes - as Sinatra sings - but we (and I think I can speak for my husband) have no regrets - and without a talked-about division of duties, we have fallen in place in that, making it work - and thus having time for ourselves - deeming that own special time the most important and never taken for granted.  

I wouldn’t change it for the world.

 

By joan larsen on 10/20/2009 4:03 am
Glenda Glynn

Joan Larsen - I have only been on wow for a short time but I must tell you that I love your posts.  And, I do so agree with you.  We started out very broke, and it was an uphil climb.  The years raising children were filled with every emotion possible.  We moved all over the country and the world.  My husband was US Air Force and our children moved with us to every nook and cranny and enoyed every minute of it.  It was an experience they will never forget.

There were many times and many years when I was both mommy and daddy to them because he was gone.  But we all survived and stayed together.  Oh yes, there were lonely years but when "he" came home, it was fun to be a whole family again.  Now the children are gone, we are retired - well I work part time, and, we like you and your husband, became even closer in our relationshiip.  Yes, you are right, it was our time now.  Time to just enjoy  each other.  And that we have done.

And, we are also separate individuals and one as one when we need to be.  He has separate interests as I do and we have many interests we share together.  And we have never talked about division of duties, we didn’t need to.  It just, somehow, fell into place.  The man can wash, iron, cook and make a bed as well as I.  (Must be that military training).  Our house is clean enough to be healthy and dirty enough to be happy.  There are too mnay other things we want to do. 

We have joined a dance club and love to "trip the light fantastic" as often as possible.  I love your reference to Sinatra because in our case, love was wonderful when it started, and now, "Love is wonderful the second time around".   

You are right —-I wouldn’t change it for the world.   

 

 

By Glenda Glynn on 10/22/2009 8:19 pm
joan larsen

Glenda - First, I thank you … and I find that your love, your marriage, your life, sounds so much like mine.  I don’t know if there is a single secret.  I don’t know if we both were just fortunate in the men we met way back then.  I know we didn’t have much wisdom when we were so young.  We too started off in the service, and I had my first baby at the base hospital and was in a single room with 24 other new mothers — none of us older than 22 I think - not knowing what to do but with these little ones in bassinets beside us from birth. 

Like you, I love Sinatra songs - and their lyrics that mean so much.  And yes, we too dance in the kitchen — and just so you know, there is one other on WOW who is just like we are also … dancing in the kitchen no less.  Frankly, we are more interesting - to others - but to each other as we have gone our own routes in our outside life, finding worlds of our own to bring back to our own private times together.  We are proud of each other’s accomplishments, caring when health problems make the world seem to collapse, and we do what it takes happily to make our joint lives work so well.  I do hope you stay on WOW  … promise you will!  Joan

By joan larsen on 10/22/2009 8:51 pm
Glenda Glynn

Joan L — I Promise I will!  We just returned from a weekend trip and I found your message.  My husband is a huge Florida Gator fan so we spent the weekend (well Friday and Saturday) in Starkville Mississippi watching the Gators play Mississippi State.  It was lots of fun.  The city is just a small Mississippi college town - long on hospitality and southern tradition.  We won the game and returned late Saturday evening.  Or I should say eary this morning.  So, of course, my husband was on the golf course for his usual Sunday tee time around 1PM.  I play golf on occasion.  Not well I might add.  So I have spent the day just sleeping late and catching up on my reading.

Tomorrow I go to work at my part time job.  I really shouldn’t call it a job.  It’s such fun.  A friend has an antique store.  So many beautiful things.  My husband kids me - "You will never draw a pay check".  I have bought several things, however, now that we have a smaller home, I have to be very selective.  We had a very large home while the children were here.  Now that they are gone we bought a smaller home here in Florida and live in a huge retirement area.  I have really enjoyed living here.  It’s a private, gated area and most of the people living here are either our age or older.  At first I was concerned about living in a retirement city but I have to admit, it really is fantastic.  And, yes, I do have one of those golf carts that I drive around.  :) 

We are living our life "our way".  Much love, lots of laughter and just enjoying each other.  Something tells me that "The best is yet to come".

Thank you for your response to my post.  I look forward to your next!  Something tells me that we are like souls.  

By Glenda Glynn on 10/25/2009 8:11 pm
Barbara

Joan, It sounds like you have a great marriage.  I feel fortunate that I do, too.  My relationship doesn’t sound at all like Carin’s.  I married fairly young.  We have two children.  I’ve always worked.  From the start, we pooled our money.  There was no mine or yours.  It was all ours.  And we always made decisions together (sometimes maddeningly…since when did you care that much about the color of the bathroom towels?)  But perhaps I was lucky, or perhaps very smart, when I chose my mate.  He does all the grocery shopping and most of the cooking.  We share the fretting over who will pick up the kids, who will stay home when one is sick.  He’s taken them to the doctor when they are sick as often as I have.  He vacuums more often than I do (although I clean the kitchen more often than he does because somehow he just does not see all the crumbs I do.)  I’ve always done the laundry because I have more things that I want hand washed or hung to dry or whatever.  We both love being outside so we very much share the yard duties.  I pay the day-to-day bills but he does most of the banking, making sure I have money in my wallet.  He usually puts gas in the cars; I usually get them washed.

We haven’t done this by counting up who does what.  It just felt right to us and we both always considered each other equals.  We’ve had shared goals and found our path toward them in a way that feels really good to us both.

By Barbara on 10/20/2009 6:39 am
Lauriate Roly

Barbara - I made sure my sweetheart read your very rational and intelligent discourse, and we both are even more confident than ever that we are going in the right direction.

By Lauriate Roly on 10/20/2009 12:23 pm
Frank Somsel

Lauriate: You made sure your "sweetheart" read this topic? You "made sure"? And he did?

Let me tell you why he read the topic, or most likely just perused it. He wants to make sure he gets his vitamin P.

Lets call a spade a spade. You know it is absolutely necessary for men to relieve themselves. Women don’t have that build up. For men its thought about every second of the day.

Some men find it easier to go along with every womens wish as long as he gets to bada boom bada bing. Some men wouldn’t care if his wife bankrupt the entire family as long as he gets it. The old saying about men not cuddling after sex is so true. Cuddling? Once its done, its done. You don’t want a man that cuddles after sex. Let him be a man.

I know many of you women might say that this not the type of relationship you have with your husband. It is. I’m not saying men and women cannot have a wonderful loving shared relationship. Of course they can. As long as he can take the skin boat to tuna town regularly, he’ll be whatever you want.

Sorry for my crass language.

By Frank Somsel on 10/23/2009 11:24 am
Lauriate Roly

Frank - How charming…and you ask, “Lauriate: You made sure your "sweetheart" read this topic? You "made sure"? And he did”.

No, “he” didn’t. “She” did.

By Lauriate Roly on 10/23/2009 12:02 pm
Chrome Toe

It doesn’t describe my marriage. but then again on another thread i posted my lifes theme song as "Bitch" by Meredith Brooks. And one of my favorite lines in it is "so take me as I am this may mean you’ll have to be a stronger man"

However… it does describe soooo many of the other marriages i see. I’d say easy 7 out of 10 maybe? that might be a lot but… close. I just had no desire to parent a grown man.

By Chrome Toe on 10/20/2009 8:44 am
Chrome Toe

Oh ya… i also have a "theory" that the superior wife thing is bad for your sex life. No one wants to sleep with their mother. and no guy wants to sleep with the woman who constantly makes him feel like he’s "less than" even if he is buying into it to make it easy on himself. and women don’t want to sleep with a man they feel is "less than" either. even subconsciously. You did the research… what do you think Carin?

By Chrome Toe on 10/20/2009 8:48 am
Green Tears

You are right on the money, Chrome Toe! I just finished reading an article about this book in the October issue of Redbook and it mentions a lower frequency of sex and lower satisfaction with any sex that happens. Lack of desire for someone you resent is also mentioned - what a surprise!!

 

By Green Tears on 10/20/2009 2:58 pm
STACY SEARS
You hit it on the head Chrome Toe.  When I was married, I took care of everything except mowing the lawn….bills, worked a bunch, etc.  My ex-husband actually believed that I should pay all the bills bc I made more money, then when I kicked him to the curb he didn’t think he should have to pay child support bc I made more money.  For the last half of my marriage I wanted nothing to do with him. We didn’t talk unless it was about the kids, if we were watching TV in the same room..it was something I wasn’t interested in so I would read then he got mad bc I wasn’t paying attention to him, he would do auto maintenance on "his" vehicle and I had to take mine in for the simplest things..like an oil change…I had no desire for sex at all.  I thought the lack of a sex drive had to do with some abuse issues from my childhood until I found myself attracted to another man.  That near affair made me realize that it was a relationship problem and not a "me" problem.  I realized that this was no example that I wanted my young daughters to follow.  I’m now involved with a man who, while isn’t so great about unprompted housework, I can count on without question for anything. He is more of a father to my girls than their biological dad could ever hope to be, he is my best friend, he can fix anything, has a great sense of humor, and even loves to snuggle.  Our relationship is what I want for my children.
By STACY SEARS on 10/21/2009 3:42 am
Mike Hicks
What a load of crap! The author is utterly blind to her inability to stop worrying about what others think of her (or to not self-criticize about her shortcomings) and just relax.

Like me, many wives have become the superior members of their union, because they have no choice in the matter.
So blind that she victimizes herself by claiming to have ‘no choice’ in the matter.

Men do less because they can, because their wives let them slide.
Men do less because they are SANE and see no need for creating weekly meal plans, color-coordinating kids clothes, vacuuming behind the furniture, or shampooing the cat.

Doing less is the male default position…
Doing what truly needs doing and not doing what doesn’t is the very essence of harmony, balance, and peace of mind.

… while the female default setting is to do more and more until we do nearly everything.
The INSANE female default position, yes. :)
By Mike Hicks on 10/20/2009 8:48 am
phyllis Doyle Pepe
Mr. Hicks: Why don’t you tell us about your marriage.
By phyllis Doyle Pepe on 10/20/2009 1:28 pm
Autumn Montgomery

You get the partner that you choose. Her husband did not suddenly become this lump; he was always a lump. This woman seems to be the type who wants to drive the relationship, she even says as much. So, own up to who you are, what type of relationship works for you, and do not dump on the spouse that you chose.

All of the men I know, have known; husband, father, brothers, friends, etc. are the type who would’ve glady picked up the cake, milk, aspirin, dinner, whatever it was that I asked. I do not treat men like idiots, but then again, I do not choose to have idiots in my life.

 

By Autumn Montgomery on 10/20/2009 1:42 pm