A Friend Stopped By | 09/24/2009 4:00 am
When High Heels Mean Danger, by Dr. Suzanne Levine

Editor’s Note: Suzanne Marin Levine, D.P.M, PC,
has been a podiatric surgeon in Manhattan for more than 20 years and is
currently on staff at New York Presbyterian Hospital, Lenox Hill
Hospital and the Center for Specialty Care in Manhattan. She is the
author of several books including My Feet Are Killing Me
and 50 Ways to Ease Foot Pain.
Dr. Levine was thrice nominated as one of America’s Top Podiatrists by
the Consumer Research Council of America and serves as the Vice
President of the International Aesthetic Foot Society. Click here to learn more about Dr. Levine.
A pair of high heels can be a great addition to any woman’s wardrobe. They can spice up an otherwise casual outfit, they can add a touch of femininity to stiff business attire and they can be the perfect punctuation for a spectacularly glamorous ensemble. But as any pump-sporting woman can attest, heels may also become the source of much grief if care is not taken.
It is important to note that no matter how fabulous they are, heels that are too high are never a good idea. The ideal heel height for every woman with healthy feet is 2.5 inches. By wearing heels over three inches for extended periods of time, we’re doing our feet major injustices. Super high heels are very impractical, and with the damage they do, wearing them might even be described as modern-day foot binding! When up on heels that high, the angle of incline is too steep, which offsets the foot’s natural balance, disrupts your gait and puts undue pressure on the weight-bearing joints all through the lower part of your body.
Knowing how to wear high heels requires some understanding of the feet. Women should be able to identify the type of foot they have, whether it be flat, high arched, wide or narrow, and should make use of this information when shoe shopping. The way to determine what type of foot you have is to analyze your footprints. Wet your foot and step onto a white piece of paper. If there is no visible arch – that is, if your whole foot is visible in the footprint – then you have a flat foot. If there is a slight "C" shape in the print where your arch should be, then you have a medium arch in your foot. The bigger the "C" in the footprint, the higher your arch. If all that is visible is the front of your foot and the back of the heel, then you have a really high-arched foot.
Some characteristics of the perfect high heel are the same across the board, but each type of foot requires a slightly different shoe feature to ensure the most comfort. If you have high-arched feet, stay away from heels that offer little or no arch support. A high-arched foot puts more pressure on the balls of the feet, so finding heels with sufficient cushioning in that area is imperative. Low-arched, flat or pronated feet should look for shoes with firm, durable heels. Cushioning under the balls of the feet is still really important for women with low arches, as each step we take forces our foot to bear pressure equivalent to three times our own body weight!
Even with knowledge of the right kind of shoes for their feet, there are some women who should never, ever wear high heels. Anyone for whom stability is an issue should not be standing more than an inch off the ground. Weak ankles on even two inches present risks for serious injury. A cute pair of kitten heels or a pair of flats with the right amount of arch support is a much safer bet.
If you are still wearing the wrong shoes, the negative effects may not show immediately, but over time you will see the results of wearing incorrect shoes. If you have high-arched feet that aren’t getting the arch support they need, you may end up with plantar fasciitis, heel spurs and pain under the balls of the foot. Wearing shoes with no support when you’ve got flat feet – for example, flip flops, flats – will further flatten and even widen your feet. And remember: Tight shoes can aggravate already existing abnormalities, like bunions and hammertoes.























33 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
This was very informative! I have unusually small feet (only 8" long), and even just a 2" heel will become very, very painful after a couple of hours. I always assumed this was because my feet were so short that they were propped up at too steep an incline (practically en pointe!) but I never knew that my very high arches also contribute to this problem.
In my younger days when I would gripe to my friends about my feet killing me they would often say, "You need to wear heels more often, you’ll get used to it." I didn’t, and I didn’t, and after reading this, I am glad that I opted for comfort all those years ago. Fashion be damned. The few "heels" I have now are just 1" or 1 1/2".
"Younger women have more pliable bones, and can accommodate the shape of their shoes more readily than the more rigid feet of their older counterparts, therefore experiencing less pain in a short span of time."
I have wide feet and high arches. When I was in my 20’s and 30’s I walked all over Manhattan in heels. Now that I don’t wear heels very often anymore, and have spent the summer in flip-flops (although I understand after a certain age one should give those up!) I find my feet quickly become sore in heels. After reading this I think I haven’t done my feet any favors and should do some serious, careful, shoe shopping. I have to wear heels this afternoon and tomorrow — and am dreading it!
Great advice! Wish I had gotten it years ago before I discovered Teva flip-flops and Chanel flats. Maybe that’s why my feet have gotten even flatter.
A couple of years ago, I had to make the decision between continuing to play tennis or wearing high heels. Playing tennis won out. For dress up, the only heels that don’t leave me limping the next day—because they are such a good fit—are Ferragamas.
I would like to know Dr. Levine’s opinion of Belgian shoes? In the winter, I wear Belgians, some of which I started wearing twenty years ago.
I have never understood the desire to wear really high heels. True, some of the shoes with high heels are breathtakingly beautiful. You try it on, your leg looks instantly longer and leaner, sexy beyond belief, but then you start to walk and its like Whoa Nelly!
Comfort has always been my number one priority. And BTW, I am really jealous of some of the ladies on this thread who were blessed with small feet. I feel like a carnival clown with my size 9’s!
I have heard that, Chrome - thank you - I’ll look.
My "basis" have both high arch and high instep; shoe salespeople tend to ignore me if I take a shoe off, first! Between my inheritance, and polio, I’ve spent a great deal of time, and money, on shoes that won’t hurt me. My one guide was to place the sole of any shoe up against the bottom of the corresponding foot to see if my foot is slightly smaller that the shoe’s sole - then I’ll buy it but I also cannot cope with a synthetic shoe sole; they make my feet BURN! All in my head I’ve been told - but it still affects my feet! ;-))
One caveat when I was younger and just "on the floors" was that Clinic Shoes could be purchased in 2 different sizes, which my Polio feet loved. Now "Birkenstock" has my adoration, which I ‘went to" during breastcancer when I could barely pick up my own feet!
I do love the high heel appearances (except for on women with spindly thin legs - they don’t seem to compliment anything then). So, when the short heel came out, in a well-made leather on leather shoe, those were my stock and trade throughout my career (with "Birks" under my desk, in my vehicles, and tucked into my shoe bags in my closets).
"I feel like a carnival clown with my size 9’s! "
Good golly, Belinda, if a 9 is carnival clown material, where does that leave me and my size 12’s? ;-) Seriously, though, I’m not terribly conscious about them…they used to be a source of endless trepidation, until I just thought about it, and I was like, what the heck? I’m getting worried because my feet might be too big by some goofy cultural standard when, in reality, they’re perfectly good feet…I could have some real issues with them, but instead I’m cringing because I have perfectly healthy, albeit large, feet? No thanks! Honestly, you have no idea what that realization did for my self-image (granted, this came in my late teens, and, when you’re a teenager, nothing is good-enough, lol ;) ). Now, I don’t feel like I need to hide my feet…I wear whatever I feel like, and try to find a happy middle ground between comfortable and stylish. :P So far, so good. The only thing I absolutely refuse to wear is white, because white makes my feet look huge — way bigger than they really are — and oddly proportioned compared to the rest of me. :P
Okay Rachel, you just taught me a lesson about keeping things in perspective.
You wear a 12? Oh my goodness, and here I am complaining about my size 9. Well a size 9 must look small to you. Just as Lila’s size 5 looks tiny to my size 9. I would think it would be hard to find shoes at size 12……
But because I love a woman with self confidence (even if we’re talking shoe size :-) I have to tip my hat to you. You go girl!
lol, thanks. ;)
You’re right, it can be very difficult to find shoes, particularly nice ones, in that size. Honestly, I think some of the shoe designers think that big feet automatically means that you have no taste. :P Oh well, it’s probably a good thing that there aren’t beautiful shoes in my size everywhere…less temptation. ;-)